A Low-Key but Subtly Luxe Beach House on Shelter Island, Courtesy of Workstead

This week we’re combing through the Remodelista archives for some of our all-time favorite summer stories. Here’s one:

Nick Gavin is a child of the once-gritty neighborhood of SoHo: “I grew up in the 1980s/90s in a loft at the corner of West Broadway and Houston; my mother ran a nonprofit, and my father was an art dealer. We frequented Fanelli Cafe and Jerry’s Cafe. My first date with my now-wife Katrin Thormann was a visit to the Judd Foundation, literally the first weekend it opened.”

So, a few years ago, when Nick came across a house with an interesting pedigree on Shelter Island, he leapt at the chance to own a sliver of history. Built in the 1940s, the modest shingled home was at one time owned by Giorgio DeLuca, the cofounder of legendary NYC food emporium Dean & DeLuca. After a time, DeLuca sold the house to Melvin Dwork, a celebrated Parsons-trained New York designer and LGBT activist.

“The original structure had pine-paneled cathedral ceilings and a floor of lagoon-green ceramic tile,” Gavin says. “I loved it, but I knew we were going to need to update (and add on to) the house, so I cold-called Workstead, a firm I have long admired.”

“Our mandate was: let’s not mess with the integrity of the house, and the Workstead team got it.”

Here’s a tour:

Photography by Matthew Williams.

workstead shelter island 223 2
Above: “We hired East Hampton-based  Geoffrey Nimmer to create the layered landscape,” Nick says.

workstead shelter island 243 2
Above: Workstead designed a glass-door-encased breezeway to connect the addition to the older structure.

workstead shelter island 844
Above: The team installed a new cedar-shingle roof and siding and reproduced an existing cedar-shingle sconce for exterior lighting.

workstead shelter island 650
Above: The couple retained the original ceramic tiles in the main living spaces; they’re cool underfoot during the hot summer months.
workstead shelter island 536
Above: The team retained the original pine-paneled cathedral ceilings in the main spaces. In the kitchen, the Sub Zero refrigerator is concealed behind a wood paneled front.

workstead shelter island 484 2
Above: A custom steel-framed daybed with a linen French-rolled mattress from Ruby Beets anchors a corner off the kitchen/dining area.

workstead shelter island 600
Above: In the kitchen (and throughout the house), the team spec’ed a brass Vola faucet.